Genre: Children’s, Young Adult
Publisher: HarperCollins Publishers
Publication Date: June 2008
Reviewed by Shaun Stevenson
In the aftermath of Harry Potter, numerous authors took up the mantle of writing stories of magic and wizardry. And Sarah Prineas offers up her debut novel, The Magic Thief, as just such an entry into the world of fantasy juvenile fiction.
Conn stumbles across a mysterious figure entering the Twilight side of the city of Wellmet, and the gutter boy picks his pockets and finds a strange stone. When Conn survives an attack from the stone, the mysterious man, Nevery Flinglas, takes the boy in. And thus begins their adventures, as Nevery tries to discover why the magic is draining out of the city and Conn just tries to figure out the mysteries surrounding his own life. Then they both discover the truth: if the magic disappears completely, all of Wellmet will be destroyed. And Conn may be the key to saving them all…
The premise seems promising, and there is mystery and magic enough to keep things interesting, but The Magic Thief just never quite caught me the way I thought it would. Things begin incredibly slowly, and for about a hundred pages, we follow the barely-speaking Conn around as he describes strange islands and the biscuits he has for breakfast every morning. The plot does pick up about halfway through, but by that time it’s fairly obvious what is really going on. And the major plot twist comes at a strange moment, and almost doesn’t feel true to the rest of the story.
But not all is lost. The setting, which is highly reminiscent of A Series of Unfortunate Events or one of Tom Becker’s Darkside novels, shines in a gothic, turn-of-the-century way. And some of the characters are highly entertaining as well. However, I couldn’t help but be reminded of Harry Potter on quite a few occasions, from the school where students learn magic to the snotty kid, Keeston, who is pretty much Draco Malfoy wearing different colored robes. But the setting itself is enough to switch up the rest of the Potter feel.
Prineas has included some fun extras as well. After most chapters, a journal entry or letter from Nevery slides in, complete with secret messages to decipher using a key in the back of the book. There’s also a map, character and location profiles, and even recipes for those biscuits that are mentioned non-stop throughout The Magic Thief.
Setting aside the plodding pace that will surely lose some readers along the way, The Magic Thief, does get some things right. And fans looking for a different sort of wizard and magic tale might just enjoy this one.